Minority Report, a science-fiction crime thriller based on a Philip K. Dick short story about a time in the future when crime can be anticipated and punished before it happens, would not spring to mind immediately as a good vehicle for the style of film composer
John Williams. The most traditional of contemporary score writers,
Williams is known for lush, sweeping, orchestral music that adds an epic scope to overgrown serials like the Star Wars series and the Indiana Jones movies. But Minority Report is also a Steven Spielberg film, and
Williams and Spielberg have worked together since the beginning of the director's film career. In his liner notes, Spielberg specifically references
Bernard Herrmann's work with
Alfred Hitchcock, and
Williams certainly takes off from
Herrmann here although characteristically, he softens the effects. Spielberg calls
Williams "the greatest musical storyteller the world of the movies has ever known," adding that, "quite often you don't need the pictures to understand the musical story that
John is telling you." If so, Minority Report must be a pretty hackneyed piece of work, since
Williams' musical storytelling touches on numerous clichés in conveying dread and suspense. The tone is simply not natural for him, and he falls back on stereotypes that sound like they come from movies from the '40s and '50s (though he also appears to borrow here and there from more recent composers such as
John Carpenter -- and even
Philip Glass -- in creating discomfiting effects). The work is certainly adequate, but for the most part it has no particular flair, remaining merely functional. It isn't until the end, with, ironically, a track called "A New Beginning," (presumably the music that plays under the credits), that the score starts to sound like
Williams, and that's because this is one of his typical warm, melodic themes. ~ William Ruhlmann