On his sixth studio album,
Ron Kaplan continues to champion pre- and non-rock popular music as performed in a jazzy manner by such predecessors as
Frank Sinatra and
Mel Tormé. Assembling a thematic collection of songs about New York, however, he was wise to leave out the late
Sinatra signature song "New York, New York" (that is to say, the 1977 movie theme that begins, "Start spreading the news"), except for a quote thrown in by pianist
Larry Dunlap at one point. As a singer, the smooth-voiced
Kaplan is actually closer to
Steve Lawrence than he is to his heroes, which becomes clear when he tries the Rodgers & Hart standard "Manhattan" at the end of the disc and gives it none of the flair that
Tormé used to. Still, the album is a thoroughly competent effort, and
Kaplan has done some digging to come up with rarely used lyrics, such as those for "Jumpin' with Symphony Sid," and introductory verses. His acoustic five-piece backup band provides excellent accompaniment, with trumpeter
Erik Jekabson and reed player
Noel Jewkes taking plenty of solos. As is usually the case with this sort of effort at re-creation, it would be more impressive if heard live in concert than it is on disc, where the comparisons with
Tormé and others inevitably kick in. But
Kaplan shouldn't mind that. As the founder and executive director of the non-profit organization American Songbook Preservation Society, he takes as his mission statement "to preserve our cultural treasure known as the Great American Songbook by performing this music at home and abroad as Ambassadors of Song." In this sense, his work is largely a tribute effort to songwriters, and it is enough to be showing their work off to advantage in the present day, not so much to compete with those who have gone before. ~ William Ruhlmann