With over two million copies sold of their 2003 breakthrough Beautiful Letdown,
Switchfoot have finally found the universal audience they've been searching for since 1999's
New Way to Be Human. Their CCM inspirations had always been more curious than self-righteous -- "We're all in this together,
Jonathan Foremanwould sing in his lyrics, "so let's figure out what it all means" -- and on Letdown, those impulses meshed ably with slick post-grunge guitars and the production of
John Fields. It's the same formula on
Nothing Is Sound,
Switchfoot's 2005 effective, but too calculated follow-up.
Fields is back in the producer's seat, and
Foreman is still striving to separate honesty from commodities and find a place for his soul to stand up straight. On songs like "Blues," "Shadow Proves the Sunshine," and "Happy Is a Yuppie Word" his vocals mix
Bono's plaintive wail with the laconic surfer drawl of fellow Southern Californian
Mark McGrath. He conveys his passion for key topics like life, death, sex, and redemption. But
Foreman's also careful not to lose that laid-back edge, so we know there's still an easygoing beach kid under that washed-out blonde mane. Together with
Foreman,
Switchfoot succeeds incredibly well with this meaningful innocuousness. Vestiges of
Nirvana remain in their melodic crunch, but there's no teeth, and nothing threatening. Instead the wrangled yells and lurching notes of "Politicians," "Lonely Nation," and "Easier Than Love" are balanced by hopeful verses, tinkling programming, and layers of airy reverb. With
Nothing Is Sound Switchfoot have realized that with universal success comes being all things to all people. So they're prayerful -- "Please Lord don't look the other way...Shine on me," goes "Shadow Proves the Sunshine" -- but they're also just plain likeable, giving "We Are One Tonight" the easygoing flair of the
Gin Blossoms.
Foreman probes the big issues with a personal touch, his band keeps the beat steady and true, and it sounds like nothing and everything at the very same time. ~ Johnny Loftus