SoCal acoustic emo band
This Wild Life return with the affable
Petaluma, their third offering for the Epitaph label. Originally a full-bore pop-punk/emo act who rocked at full volume, the core duo of
Kevin Jordan (vocals, guitar) and
Anthony Del Grosso (guitar) reconfigured themselves in 2013 as an acoustic songwriter act with emo sensibilities. First with 2014's
Clouded, then on 2016's
Low Tides, they explored the softer side of the emo sphere, from brooding balladry to dreamy harmonic pop. Sometimes it worked and sometimes it didn't, but they managed to earn themselves a fervent fan base and acceptance among the Warped Tour crowd as one of the few representatives of that scene's gentler side. In a decided attempt to move away from the darker-hued vibes of
Low Tides,
Jordan and
Del Grosso opt for a brighter, more optimistic tone on
Petaluma. From the breezy and romantic folk-pop of "Catie Rae" and "College Kids" to the soaring indie folk of "Never Believe," the songs are delivered with unflinching earnestness in a slickly arranged format that unfortunately doesn't do the band many favors. As dictated by their format, there's none of the gusto or danger of full-on electric emo or punk, and the songs -- as well-meant as they seem to be -- don't quite hold enough water to survive the bland contemporary folk-pop arrangements, leaving
This Wild Life caught in a sort of tonal limbo.