Producer and record executive
Joel Dorn (who worked with
Don McLean previously on his 1974 album
Homeless Brother) assembled this retrospective CD/DVD collection by going through
McLean's archives. Although no indication is given of the sources of the material, a majority of it has been previously released, starting with the original hit recording of "American Pie," licensed from EMI Special Products. The rest of the collection dates from after 1976, when
McLean, for the most part, controlled his own recordings, and there is a heavy complement from albums issued on his own Don McLean Records label, notably "Vincent (Starry, Starry Night)," "Crying," "Homeless Brother," and "And I Love You So" (the last a duet with
Nanci Griffith) from the live Starry Starry Night album; "El Paso" from
Don McLean Sings Marty Robbins; "My Saddle Pals and I" from
The Western Album; and "You've Got to Share" from
You've Got to Share: Songs for Children. Previously unreleased tracks include
McLean versions of the standards "Love Me Tender," "(It Was) A Very Good Year," and "TB Blues," and a
McLean original, the
Rolling Stones-like "Run, Diana Run." Neither a greatest-hits collection nor a best-of, exactly, the album is an idiosyncratic compilation that nevertheless gives a good sense of
McLean's accomplishments as a songwriter and an interpretive singer. (Equally idiosyncratic are
Dorn's liner notes, which are more about him than they are about
McLean.) The DVD contains a 20-minute home movie of a rehearsal by
McLean and
the Jordanaires for
McLean's 1984 Carnegie Hall holiday concert; the 1991 music video for the politically charged rocker "Headroom"; and the duet with
Griffith on "And I Love You So" from the 2000 home video Starry Starry Night. ~ William Ruhlmann