Since acoustic and roots music have always formed the base of their respective musics, it seems natural for
John Sebastian and
David Grisman to cut an album for Acoustic Disc (
Grisman's label). The pairing is similar to that of
Dylan and
Happy Traum way back in 1971 for several nice acoustic duos at the end of Bob Dylan's Greatest Hits, Vol. 2. In both instances, one gains the impression of two friends jamming just for the fun of it, a back-porch authenticity re-created in the studio. The difference, however, says a thing or two about just what it means when friends get together and jam. On the
Dylan/
Traum sides, the overall quality is quite professional, especially when comparing their version of "You Ain't Goin' Nowhere" to the one recorded with
the Band for
The Basement Tapes. The newer version, then, may sound off-the-cuff, but
Dylan and
Traum have worked hard to create a spry, clean take.
Sebastian and
Grisman are also professional, though their performance level never reaches that of
Dylan and
Traum's.
Sebastian is in good voice, and the acoustic interplay between his guitar and
Grisman's mandolin is nice; furthermore, the whole affair is relaxed, much like
Grisman's previous effort with
John Hartford and
Mike Seeger on
Retrograss. As enjoyable as it is to listen to two old friends get together and jam, though,
Satisfied is too laid-back, with a number of so-so songs mixed in with classics, and some songs overstay their welcome. The entire project would have been strengthened by a better batch of songs and tighter performances. Fans of
Sebastian and
Grisman will undoubtedly want to tune in to see what these two old pros have been up to, even if
Satisfied does have the sound and feel of a home recording. ~ Ronnie D. Lankford, Jr.