Uh-Huh found
John Mellencamp coming into his own, but he perfected his heartland rock with
Scarecrow. A loose concept album about lost innocence and the crumbling of small-town America,
Scarecrow says as much with its tough rock and gentle folk-rock as it does with its lyrics, which remain a weak point for
Mellencamp. Nevertheless, his writing has never been more powerful: "Rain on the Scarecrow" and "Small Town" capture the hopes and fears of Middle America, while "Lonely Ol' Night" and "Rumbleseat" effortlessly convey the desperate loneliness of being stuck in a dead-end life. Those four songs form the core of the album, and while the rest of the album isn't quite as strong, that's only a relative term, since it's filled with lean hooks and powerful, economical playing that make
Scarecrow one of the definitive blue-collar rock albums of the mid-'80s. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine