These discs restore to the catalog
Alexander Gibson and the
Scottish National Orchestra's 1977 recordings of ten of Sibelius' tone poems. Most of the favorites are here -- Finlandia and En Saga, but not, however, Valse Triste -- and most of the performances are first-rate.
Gibson was a powerfully individualistic conductor whose Sibelius interpretations were dramatically heroic at their best.
Gibson is at his best in the less well-known works. His Night Ride and Sunrise is evocative and ecstatic. His The Oceanides is supple and mysterious. Some listeners might find his Tapiola too fast, but none would deny its strength. And all listeners will find his Luonnotar with soprano
Phyllis Bryn-Julson overwhelmingly compelling. With the technically superb and brilliantly colorful playing of the
Scottish National Orchestra,
Gibson's Sibelius recordings are arguably the best English Sibelius recordings between
Barbirolli and
Colin Davis. Chandos' 2004 remastering of the 1977 recordings is superlative. The originals were hard, harsh, and glassy, but these reissues are deep, lush, and warm.