This album is a wonderful way to discover the work of
Tommy Makem separate from that of
the Clancy Brothers. Although a studio recording (made in New Hampshire, where
Makem lived in his last decades), it is strongly representative, in its content and presentation, of the artist's live shows: the repertory is supported by
Makem's personal notes on each song, making the CD almost as much a history lesson as a delightful listening experience (had it been made a decade or so later, it would probably have been a live show on DVD).
Makem is in superb voice on a range of material, traditional and original, that spans three continents and several centuries, all to mostly acoustic accompaniment that wouldn't have been too different at the outset of his career. On a cautionary note for folk purists, there are synthesizers credited among the instruments, but these are used with such subtlety that one can easily miss their presence. By this time in his career,
Makem had become the Celtic equivalent of
Pete Seeger, his range and repertory transcending category, and in his case something even more -- there is a subtle actor-ish quality to his work here (in keeping with his aspirations in that area) that makes these recordings not just musically compelling but gives them a dramatic edge as well, whether the material at hand is light or serious. And the listening experience is, thus, further enriched beyond the merits of the music itself. ~ Bruce Eder