In 1955, Capitol Records signed
Dick Haymes and attempted to do for him what it had done for
Frank Sinatra a few years earlier, resurrect his career. Due to a combination of personal and business problems,
Haymes had fallen far from his mid-'40s peak, when he was a major rival to
Sinatra among the new crop of solo singers emerging from the big bands. The Capitol sojourn led to 12 recording sessions between December 20, 1955, and April 4, 1957, that produced two LPs,
Rain or Shine and
Moondreams, and a few singles, only one of which, "Two Different Worlds," managed a brief stay in the charts. The recordings were out of print for decades, but were championed by some critics, making this thorough two-CD set, compiled by Ken Barnes, a welcome reissue. It reveals that, if the recordings are not nearly as impressive as
Haymes' revisionist supporters have claimed, they are nevertheless creditable. It may be that the tendency to overrate them comes from that very competence; given
Haymes' notorious troubles of the '50s, from reported alcoholism to bizarre legal battles and his stormy, tabloid-splashed marriage to
Rita Hayworth, it's amazing that he sounds as unruffled as he does in recording sessions that began only eight days after his divorce from
Hayworth became final. Actually, it might have helped if more of the angst of his recent experiences had leaked into the performances. The approach on the two LPs (which occupy the first 12 tracks of each CD) was the same: to choose a collection of vintage copyrights almost entirely from the '30s and '40s, many of them previously recorded by
Haymes ("It Might as Well Be Spring," "You'll Never Know," "Little White Lies," etc.) and set them to '50s-style arrangements mixing lush orchestral charts with jazzy small-band settings, all put together by
Haymes' musical director,
Ian Bernard. That sounds like the same formula employed for
Sinatra's Capitol work, but the big difference comes in the singing.
Sinatra sounded very different on Capitol in the '50s from the way he had sounded on Columbia Records in the '40s -- grittier, darker, older, more emphatic.
Haymes tries most of the time to sound much as he did in the '40s, which means that the flaw in these performances is the same one that dogged his career in every aspect. Whether singing or acting, he always relied on a smooth, polished delivery, a surface effect, to get across. As an actor, he was a wooden, humorless pretty boy, which is why he never really made it in the movies. As a singer, he was a smooth, bland, uninvolved deliverer of the lyrics, relying on his rich timbre to please his listeners. That worked beautifully in the '40s when it was the dominant style, but by the mid-'50s
Sinatra had taught audiences to expect more.
Haymes' apologists cite the usual reasons for his failure to make a
Sinatra-like comeback, including lack of promotion and his personal demons. But there were musical reasons as well, and they are heard here.
Bernard provides appropriate '50s backings, but
Haymes continues to sing as though he's still in the '40s. By 2006, a later generation might be more willing to just luxuriate in the beauty of his tone, but it's really no surprise that no one was interested 50 years earlier. (Barnes has dug up some interesting, if minor, unreleased material, including a session with
Jackie Gleason as bandleader that finds
Haymes trying to navigate a
Gleason adaptation of the "Habanera" from
Bizet's Carmen.) ~ William Ruhlmann