Paxton's last 1960s album was his most musically ambitious of the decade, getting into both some full folk-rock arrangements and some orchestrated Baroque-folk or symphonic folk. The expansion of musical color was admirable, with contributions from some name players like
David Bromberg,
Richard Davis, and
Hubert Laws. But
Paxton was never the most adaptable of the folkies to rock, and the songs he came up with for the LP were not among his best. The rollicking, even a bit sloppy, folk-rock of "Bishop Cody's Last Request" sounded much more forced than his gentle ballads, like "Wish I Had a Troubadour." The 15-minute "The Iron Man" might be the most unusual 1960s
Tom Paxton track of all, recalling slightly earlier overly ambitious Baroque-folk poem epics like
Phil Ochs' "When in Rome" and
Tim Buckley's "Goodbye and Hello," though without as much melodic or vocal distinction. Ultimately, the most satisfying track was the contemplative "All Night Long," which boasted the album's best tune and (courtesy of
Joshua Rifkin) understated orchestral arrangement, and which
Paxton has described as a lament for the troubled times of America in general in 1968. ~ Richie Unterberger