By the time of their third LP,
Pearls Before Swine's mainstay
Tom Rapp hadn't changed much in his approach. He was still singing inscrutable folk-rock-psychedelic songs with a crackly lisp, with melodies that were pleasant but didn't really stick in the memory. The chief difference, if any, was that by this point
Pearls Before Swine was less of a group and more a front for
Rapp working with various other musicians. Only Wayne Harley remained from the lineup on the first album; the drums, in fact, were handled by esteemed jazz veteran
Grady Tate. Perhaps working for a major label allowed for more time in honing the arrangements, which employed horns, strings, celeste, lugubrious orchestration, periodic odd sound effects, and some backup vocals by Elisabeth Rapp. At times,
Rapp sounded almost normal, as on the cover of
Bob Dylan's "I Shall Be Released" (the only non-original) and the easygoing country-rock of "If You Don't Want To." What to make, though, of a song about a "Frog in the Window," presented in both a hurdy-gurdy good-time version and a more spaced-out one? Or the French-sung "Mon Amour," in which
Rapp wanders into
Astrud Gilberto territory? The collision of weirdness and ordinariness is strange enough to make one wonder whether
Lambchop, decades later, found some inspiration for their own unfathomable mundane art songs in old
Pearl Before Swine albums, though
Pearl Before Swine was less self-conscious and more interesting. But on
These Things Too, they weren't that interesting. ~ Richie Unterberger