Thin Lizzy was originally conceived as a power trio in the image of
Cream and the Jimi Hendrix Experience, but
Eric Bell lacked the charisma of those groups' guitarists, forcing vocalist/bassist
Philip Lynott to take center stage from day one. Despite his already poetic, intensely personal lyrics,
Lynott was only beginning to develop as a songwriter, and the band's unfocused, folk-infused early efforts are a far cry from their mid-'70s hard rock glory. Recorded on a shoestring budget, their self-titled debut is surprisingly mellow; many songs, such as "Clifton Grange Hotel" and "The Friendly Ranger of Clontarf Castle," sound confused and unfinished. Quiet ballads like "Honesty Is No Excuse," "Eire," and "Saga of the Ageing Orphan" abound, while supposed rockers such as "Ray-Gun" and "Return of the Farmer's Son" fall remarkably flat. In fact,
Lizzy only bare their claws on "Look What the Wind Blew In," a gutsy rocker that hints at things to come. ~ Eduardo Rivadavia