Saves the Day fans will happily devour
Ups & Downs, as it presents a wealth of archival and rare stuff from one of the genre's more veteran groups. "Sell My Old Clothes, I'm Off to Heaven" wins the best title blue ribbon; it's taken from the same 2000 session as "A Drag in D Flat." "Hold" and "I'm Sorry I'm Leaving" were previously available on
Saves the Day's 1999 acoustic EP, but
Chris Conley's liner-note insights into their recordings are revealing. Fan favorite "Jessie & My Whetstone" appears twice, once acoustically and again in live, electrified form. It's a real teenage tearjerker, and one of
Conley's songwriting highlights. Sure, punk-pop-inflected emoticons are a dime a dozen. But in something like the bittersweet pal tribute "Way His Collar Falls," he knows just how to combine lyric with melody to make the song something more than simply youthfully exuberant. His own age shows on the early
Saves demo material that makes up the majority of
Ups & Downs' second half -- the songs have a ragged, holy-crap-we're-a-band urgency. They also sound a lot like
Green Day most of the time. A couple covers round out the set here, including "Clash City Rockers" and
the Descendents. Check the rough mixing on the
Clash tune -- it's, like, 7" quality at best, dude. Considering
Saves the Day operates in a world where 7"s are largely extinct, the inclusion just makes
Ups & Downs more visceral for fans. Now, what are you waiting for? Go out and start your own band. ~ Johnny Loftus