This LP, a certified double-platinum album, captures
Campbell's appeal at his most mainstream, mixing midtempo country-pop, spiced by a smooth if unambitious cover of
Otis Redding's "(Sittin' On) The Dock of the Bay" and the prettiest version of
Tim Hardin's "Reason to Believe" ever done. The latter two make the album hipper than
Campbell himself seemed to most of us at the time. On the other hand, there's ample romantic pop here, including his heartfelt, string-laden performance of the
McKuen/
Brel "If You Go Away" and "Words." Right there at the center of
Campbell's appeal is the still-beautiful title track (for which he had composer
Jimmy Webb's organ hauled to the studio to re-create its exact sound from the demo) and "Dreams of the Everyday Housewife," alongside midtempo country-pop like Billy Ed Wheeler's sprightly "Ann" and
Campbell's own "Fate of Man."
Sonny Curtis' "The Straight Life" is closer in spirit to the Mary Tyler Moore theme song (still a year or so away) than to the work of an ex-
Buddy Holly compadre, and
Sonny Bono's singsongy divorce ode, "You Better Sit Down Kids," did little to enhance the future congressman's musical credibility. He saves the best for last" "That's Not Home," the most heartfelt song here. The production is excellent throughout, if a little overly reliant on strings. ~ Bruce Eder