Five years after their last collaboration, pianist
Kenny Barron and bassist
Dave Holland reunite for the elegant and swinging 2020 trio date
Without Deception.
Barron and
Holland's partnership goes back decades to at least the mid-'80s and
Barron's trio album
Scratch. On 2014's
The Art of Conversation, they played as a duo. Here, they are joined by drummer
Johnathan Blake, who previously worked with
Barron on his equally engaging 2016 trio album
Book of Intuition and 2018 quintet recording
Concentric Circles. All of which is to say that each of these players brings his deep creative ties and a wealth of personal musical experience to this project. Having three virtuoso musicians could lead to a struggle for dominance on any given song, but
Barron,
Holland, and
Blake play with a generosity and spirit as they buoy each other's performances throughout. There's a deep textural quality to their sound with
Barron's stacked voicings tastefully underpinned by
Holland's warm bass lines and
Blake's delicately kinetic rhythms. Although they never stray too far afield of the main diatonic and chromatic tonalities of a given song, warm harmonies and inventive note choices abound. There's an underlying
Thelonious Monk influence running through much of the album, especially in the jaunty
Barron-penned title track, with its rambling up and down lines and bright melody. The trio underline the connection with their snappy album-closing take on
Monk's lesser-played song "Worry Later." They expand upon this influence in their own way throughout, with tracks like the opening Latin groover "Porto Alegri" and
Mulgrew Miller's burnished, minor-key number "Second Thoughts," both of which showcase
Barron's richly enveloping and elegant keyboard skills. Similarly engaging are the pianist's romantic ballad "Until Then," the driving post-bop cut "Speed Trap," and the trio's dreamy, off-kilter rendition of
Sumi Tonooka's "Secret Places." ~ Matt Collar