German countertenor
Andreas Scholl is known not only for his gorgeous voice, but gutsy programming, and he may never have been more gutsy than in this set of German Romantic and proto-Romantic (an important distinction of which more in a moment) songs. It's pretty clear that any of the composers included on this album would have doubled over with laughter at the idea of hearing his music sung by a countertenor, and the highly gendered quality of the music of the 19th century is one of its primary motivating forces. Thus there's real excitement in hearing that
Scholl does, in fact, pull it off. Quoted in the notes, he offers the expected platitudes about how what matters in singing lieder is not voice type but connection with the music. Yet there's more than that to what's happening here.
Scholl does not simply program a typical lieder recital; rather, he tailors his repertoire to his unusual voice.
Haydn, with three songs, and
Mozart (two) are overrepresented, and this helps bridge the acceptance gap: the simple, folklike melodies of these songs (
Haydn's are in English) require less suspension of disbelief than do the full-blown Romantic pieces. Moving into
Schubert,
Scholl makes some interesting choices. The famed Ave Maria is a piece of sheer Italianate melody that works beautifully in
Scholl's voice; it's of a piece with any number of his earlier recordings. In Der Tod und das Mädchen, D. 531 (Death and the Maiden, the source of a tremendous set of variations in one of
Schubert's string quartets),
Scholl sings both of the dialogic parts himself: the Maiden is his usual countertenor voice, while he sings Death as a baritone. The strangeness of this leapfrogs, as it were, that of hearing a countertenor sing
Schubert. Add to these the fact that
Scholl mostly avoids songs with romantic and erotic themes, and it adds up to an album that continually surprises rather than one that is trying to force something into a mold where it doesn't belong. Accompanist
Tamar Halperin stays mostly out of the way, which is the right thing to do, and in all
Scholl can claim another in his string of triumphs, even if it's maybe not the first one for newcomers to start out with.