Among contemporary Polish composers, Henryk Gorécki has nearly outdistanced the long-established popularity of
Krzysztof Penderecki, partly due to his willingness to abandon the international style fostered in Darmstadt in favor of a calm, quiet, and accessible style that nonetheless effectively takes on the challenge of Poland's disastrous place in the scheme of world events in the twentieth century. While Gorécki gets the glory, at least in the United States, one Polish composer who has been plowing the same field for easily as long is
Wojciech Kilar (pronounced "hVoy-Jee Kee-lahr"), and yet his name is mainly only known to fanciers of film music. Chances are, no matter who you are, you've heard it; among
Kilar's film credits are such scores as Bram Stoker's Dracula, The Ninth Gate, Death and the Maiden, and The Pianist. Kilar: Piano Concerto is the second of Naxos' attempts to bring
Kilar's generally excellent music to a more general audience, and while it's good, it's perhaps a little less than ideal.
The main work,
Kilar's Piano Concerto, gets off to a beautiful start, but about five minutes into it seems to lose its focus. That might not be much of a deterrent if one is nuts about
Kilar already, and admittedly Tchaikovsky likewise loses his focus after the big opening tune of his Piano Concerto No. 1 and this has hardly stopped it from being played and recorded countless times. While
Kilar's effort remains attractive-sounding throughout, it's hard to warm up to it as you're not sure why he's going where he's going. The closing Toccata also sounds a little too much like
Louis Andriessen. Mother of God, dating from 1979, and Koscielec 1909 from 1976 are a bit more on the money, although some may object to the violent outbursts in Mother of God. Grey Mist, for baritone and orchestra, is really the best and most representative piece on Kilar: Piano Concerto, although its enjoyment is hampered somewhat by the lack of a text; this you can find on the Naxos website, although many may not bother with this additional step.
The performances are decent, as is the recording, which has a rather dark, burnished quality about it that, like the collection itself, is less than ideal. To get to know
Kilar at his best, you really can't beat the album Requiem Father Kolbe on Jade, which will also bring you Koscielec 1909. Nonetheless, Kilar: Piano Concerto might well satisfy the already converted.